Back

Top 25 Best Christmas Cookie Recipes for Irresistible Festivity

Recipes

Top 25 Best Christmas Cookie Recipes for Irresistible Festivity

Published 18.12.2023

Share this article


Imagine entering a kitchen that exudes the lovely scents of vanilla and spices, where the sound of kneading dough and laughter combine to create a merry atmosphere. This recipe book is your pass to making 25 of the tiniest, tastiest Christmas dishes, all creatively and traditionally combined.

The action portion now: Put on your apron, get your supplies and ingredients, and start your baking journey. Let your kitchen be a place where innovation and history collide, where each batch of cookies you bake is a reflection of your love and commitment. Keep in mind that the experience, the education, and the delight that accompany each step—from kneading the dough to eating that first delicious bite—are more important than perfection in this case.

Soft Christmas Cookies: Their Magic

A certain charm exists in the texture of delicate Christmas cookies. They release bursts of festive spices and a buttery taste as they melt gently on your tongue. These cookies bring back fond memories of winter festivities throughout the globe and make a delectable contrast to the warm weather. From the smooth, welcoming texture to the lingering sweetness, every mouthful is a fantastic adventure. 

The Christmas cookies recipe is easy, but it's not just a treat for the holidays—it's the centre of family get-togethers, a source of nostalgia, and a conversation starter.

Important Components and Equipment 

Soft Christmas cookie baking is a fun project, particularly if you have the necessary supplies and equipment on hand. The section of our guide serves as your go-to resource for gathering all the supplies you'll need for your baking adventure. Here, we'll cover the necessities, such as flour and a mixing bowl, to make sure you have everything you need to bake delicious, easy Christmas cookies. 

Recall that with baking, preparation is half the fight. This Christmas season, make sure your kitchen is prepared to become a festive bakery.

Ingredients for making Christmas cookies

Gathering Your Baking Arsenal

Every baker needs their tools, and when it comes to Christmas cookies, having the right equipment makes all the difference. Here’s what you’ll need:

  • Mixing bowls: A variety of sizes for different stages of mixing.
  • Measuring cups and spoons: Accuracy is key in baking.
  • Electric mixer: Saves time and gives you smooth dough.
  • Baking sheets: The base for baking your cookies.
  • Parchment paper or silicone mats: These help in easy removal and cleanup.
  • Cookie cutters: To shape your cookies in festive designs.
  • Rolling pin: For evenly flattened dough.
  • Wire rack: Essential for cooling cookies to maintain texture.
  • Decorating tools: Think piping bags and spatulas for those final touches.

Having such tools is the way to success because, as a famous chef Johnny Luzzini says: "Baking is about multitasking. If you're organised and prepared, that's half the battle."

Looking for a platform that will help you sell your cakes?  Do it with us! Sign up now

The Must-Have Ingredients List

The Christmas shortbread recipe consists of simple and high-quality ingredients. Here's your shopping list before you start baking:

  • Flour: The base for your cookies; usually all-purpose.
  • Sugars: White for sweetness, brown for a moist texture.
  • Butter: Unsalted to control the flavour.
  • Eggs: They add structure and richness.
  • Leavening agents: Baking powder and baking soda for lift.
  • Spices: Think cinnamon, nutmeg, and ginger for that Christmas aroma.
  • Vanilla extract: For that hint of rich flavour.
  • Salt: Just a pinch to balance the sweetness.
  • Add-ins: Like chocolate chips, nuts, or dried fruits for variety.

Creating the perfect cookie dough is crucial for soft, delicious cookies. Here’s how to nail it:

  • Room temperature ingredients: This helps in easy mixing.
  • Sift dry ingredients: Avoid lumps and ensure even mixing.
  • Creaming: Mix butter and sugar well for a fluffy base.
  • Mixing: Combine until just incorporated; overmixing can make cookies tough.
  • Chilling: Rest the dough in the fridge before rolling to prevent spreading.
  • Rolling consistency: Aim for even thickness for uniform baking.
  • Baking Time: Don’t overbake; cookies firm up as they cool.
  • Cooling: Let them sit on the baking sheet for a bit, then move to a wire rack.

Recall that every stage presents an opportunity to add affection and attention to your baking, culminating in cookies that will undoubtedly become the talk of the town this holiday season.

Traditional Recipes for Soft Christmas Cookies

Traditional soft Christmas cookie recipes capture the warm spirit of the occasion. These classic recipes, which range from gingerbread treats to classic sugar cookies, make gatherings cozy and happy. Look through a carefully chosen collection that speaks to the coziness of the holidays for the best Christmas cookies recipe ever that embodies the festive mood.

Shortbread Cookies

Traditional Christmas shortbread cookies

This Сhristmas shortbread cookies recipe is well-liked due to its ease of preparation and adaptability. Begin by combining the flour, sugar, eggs, and softened butter to make the basic dough. Cut the dough into festive shapes after rolling it out. After baking till softly golden, the exciting part: decorating! These are delightful as presents or simply to savour on a nice summer evening with a cup of tea.

Gingerbread Сookies

An easy recipe for Christmas gingerbread cookies

Christmas is best experienced through gingerbread biscuits. The dough is rolled out and cut into traditional forms. It is a flavourful combination of ginger, cinnamon, and sweet molasses. Their characteristic soft texture comes from baking them until they are firm. Whether you choose to decorate them with a straightforward icing grin or a more complex ensemble of icing and candies, decorating these gingerbread figurines may become a treasured Christmas tradition.

Snickerdoodles

Snickerdoodles and sugar snickers

Snickerdoodles are a beloved treat for fans of cinnamon since they're incredibly delicate and fragrant. The dough gets its pillowy texture and somewhat acidic flavour from the cream of tartar. Encased in a mixture of cinnamon and sugar, these cookies have a crispy outside and a soft inside when baked. This crinkle doodle happiness is perfect for a festive table with loved ones.

Stars of Vanilla Almonds

Christmas cookies with almonds and vanilla

Try these almond stars with vanilla for a hint of sophistication. After rolling out the dough and cutting it into star shapes, it is laced with ground almonds and vanilla. These cookies have a soft, melt-in-your-mouth quality after baking. Not only do they taste amazing, but a small coating of powdered sugar may offer a sweet finish that will look stunning on your Christmas table.

Joyful Peppermint Bars

Cookies with mint flavour and crushed lollipop sticks

These cookies infuse your Christmas table with a refreshing punch of peppermint. The peppermint extract flavouring in the dough provides a cool contrast to the decadent chocolate coating that they are dipped in after baking. A festive touch is added by sprinkling crushed candy canes on top. They make a delicious dessert to finish a holiday dinner or a special treat over the festive season.

Soft Cookies with Fruit Infusion

Indulge in soft and delightful fruit-infused cookies that will surely tantalize your taste buds and make your holiday gatherings extra special.

Looking for a cake for your event? Explore cake makers who create classic Christmas cookie recipes. Learn more

Embrace the flavours of the season with these delectable creations, and let the sweetness and tanginess of these cookies transport you to a magical winter wonderland.

Christmas cookies with cranberries

Imagine the tangy taste of cranberries meeting the zest of oranges in a soft, buttery cookie. That’s what these cranberry orange cookies are all about. Begin with a basic dough, add orange zest and dried cranberries for a pop of colour, and bake until tender. Once baked, a thin orange glaze gives it even more zest. Tangy, sweet, and oh-so-festive, these cookies are like a blast of Christmas happiness in every mouthful.

Gems in a Lemon Glaze

Lemon glaze cookies

This is your ideal cookie, lemon lovers. Start with a buttery, zesty, lemon-infused dough, bake it until it's barely soft, and then pour over it a tart lemon glaze. The ideal harmony of sour and sweet may be found in these lemon-glazed gems. Their vivid flavour adds a new dimension to your Christmas cookie choices, like a beam of sunshine. Watch them vanish as you serve them!

Cherry Kiss Cookies

Christmas cookies with cherries and almonds

Try these cherry almond kisses for a delicious and nutty treat. For a soft and chewy texture, include ground almonds and chopped cherries in the dough. Bake these beauties and sprinkle almonds on top for crunch. A delightfully rich and refreshing taste is provided by the mix of cherries and almonds, making it a wonderful Christmas joy.

Raspberry Linzer Cookies

 Linzer Cookies with raspberry jam

These Raspberry Linzer Wonders are a holiday staple, and they're modelled after the traditional Linzer torte. They have a dab of raspberry jam in the centre and tender dough with a hint of almond flavour. They look as pretty as they taste. Your Christmas cookie spread will have a magical touch when dusted with powdered sugar, giving the appearance of being caressed by winter snowfall.

Chocolate Addict Eden

A lovely mix of rich cocoa-infused delicacies, such as double chocolate fudge rounds and mint chocolate swirls, make up Chocolate Lover's Paradise. These rich but delicious treats go so well with the spicy and warm flavours of Christmas gingerbread biscuits.

Rounds of Double Chocolate Fudge

Christmas cookies with melted chocolate

These are for serious chocolate fans. Imagine soft dough that has been blended with rich chocolate and melted chocolate, then baked to produce a fudgy, decadent delight. A beautiful chocolate frosting completes each cookie, making it the ideal treat for everyone who likes chocolate. The Double Chocolate Fudge Rounds are rich, soft, and completely mouthwatering.

Cookies of Macadamia Nuts with White Chocolate

 Cookies with macadamia nuts and white chocolate

These decadent treats are made by mixing creamy white chocolate with crunchy macadamia nuts in a soft cookie dough. Your cookies will have the perfect balance of flavours and textures after baking until they're soft and golden. White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Dreams add a sophisticated touch to your holiday spread and combine well with your lollies.

Chocolate Mint Swirls Cookies

Soft Christmas cookies with chocolate and mint

These Mint Chocolate Swirls are an ideal illustration of how mint and chocolate complement each other like clockwork. The dough is infused with peppermint and marbled with melted chocolate for an eye-catching appearance. They're a delicious, chocolaty, minty, and soft complement to your assortment of Christmas cookies.

Chocolate Chip Pleasures with Pecans

Chocolate cookies with nuts

Add some nuts to the traditional chocolate chip cookie to make it even better. Packed with chocolate chips and pecan bits, the dough bakes out to be a tender, chewy treat. Enjoy these Chocolate Chip Pecan Pleasures with a glass of milk or a cup of coffee for a warm, comforting treat with a unique holiday twist.

Nutty Delights

Nutty Creations offers a variety of nut-filled cookie recipes such as pecan fingerprint pie and pecan snowball. These flavoursome treats harmonise exquisitely with the diverse flavours found in German Christmas cookies.

Walnut Snowball Cookies

Cookies in the form of balls sprinkled with powdered sugar

These snowball cookies are a winter wonderland in a bite. Imagine a dough rich with chopped walnuts, formed into balls, and baked to a gentle golden brown. Once they're out of the oven, each cookie gets a snowy coat of powdered sugar. The result? A texture that melts in your mouth and has an enticing nutty crunch. With each taste of these treats, the spirit of the holidays is brought to mind.

Pie Crust Thumbprints

Imagine the warm, comforting tastes of a pecan pie in cookie form! The foundation of these thumbprints is soft and buttery. Create a little well in each and pour in a sticky, sugary concoction of finely chopped pecans. The filling solidifies into a gooey, pie-like centre while they bake. It's like eating a little piece of pecan pie with every cookie — perfect for the holiday season.

Chocolate Hazelnut Cookies

Christmas chocolate cookies with nuts

These are ideal for people who want a little bit of elegance in their cookies. Start with a dough infused with hazelnuts, bake, and then dip them halfway into melted chocolate while they are still warm. Every mouthful is a taste explosion because of the harmony of the soft cookie, crunchy hazelnuts, and creamy chocolate.

Pistachio Cranberry Cookies

 Pistachio and cranberry Christmas cookies

These cookies are a vibrant treat. For a festive appearance, include chopped pistachios and dried cranberries in your dough. The cranberries provide a touch of acidity, while the pistachios lend a delicate nuttiness. These rounds are ideal for your Christmas cookie tray since, once baked, they are not only delicious but also a visual feast.

Holiday Flavours With Spices

Holiday Spice & Everything Nice blends flavourful spices like cloves, nutmeg, and cinnamon with delicious delicacies to encapsulate the spirit of the holiday season. These tastes are ideal for frigid winter days and happy festivities because they bring warmth to every bite.

Rolling Cinnamon Sugar Cookies

Soft cookies with cinnamon and sugar

Imagine the combination of the sharpness of sugar cookies and the comfort of cinnamon buns. The first step in making these goodies is rolling a swirl of cinnamon sugar into a soft dough. Slice, bake, and then frost with a sugary glaze to resemble traditional cinnamon rolls. These tastes are lively and celebratory, making them ideal for a leisurely day enjoyed with a cup of tea.

Snickerdoodle with Cardamom

Christmas cookies with cardamom

Take your Christmas baking to the next level with these star-shaped Snickerdoodles. These cookies, which have a crunchy outside and a soft, spicy within, are rolled in sugar before baking and are infused with the warm, fragrant fragrance of cardamom. These are a sophisticated twist on the traditional Snickerdoodle that will elevate your holiday confections.

Cookies with Nutmeg Eggnog

Flavoured cookies with eggnog

The spirit of the holidays is encapsulated in these little cookies. Nutmeg and a dash of eggnog give them a flavour that bakes up into soft, fragrant delights. Their added sweetness is enhanced with a straightforward eggnog glaze, which makes them the ideal side dish for your Christmas get-togethers. Every taste of these is like a tiny drink of Christmas cheer.

Inventive Holiday Recipes

Unique holiday creations creatively reimagine beloved classics to capture the spirit of the season. These inventive cookie creations bring astonishment and delight to holiday get-togethers with their unusual forms and taste combinations.

Crescent Pistachio-Cranberry Cookies

 Soft shortbread cookies

These Pistachio Cranberry Crescent Cookies will give your holiday baking a distinctive touch. The dough has a deep, nutty flavour and is a lovely blend of butter and crushed pistachios. To add a pop of fruitiness, fold in sour cranberries. Form the dough into nice crescents and bake till golden brown. Shape the dough into beautiful crescents and bake until golden brown. Before serving, add a little powdered sugar to make the cookies sweet. 

Apricot Linzer Cookies

Apricot Linzer cookies

These cookies, called Apricot Linzer Cookies, are a lovely fusion of flavour and custom. With their tender almond dough, customisable forms, and delicious apricot filling, these treats are visually appealing and delicious. Delicate cutouts on the top layer show the jam within, giving it a visually appealing appearance. They have a festive, wintry air to them after one more coating of powdered sugar.

Pecan and Butterscotch Thumbprint Cookies

Pecan cookies example

Imagine having a soft, buttery cookie that combines the rich, nutty flavour of nuts with the deep, sweet flavour of butterscotch. These Butterscotch Pecan Thumbprint Cookies give you just that. These cookies are delicious, but they also serve as a wonderful example of how a few simple ingredients can come together to create something quite remarkable.

Frosted Eggnog Gingerbread Cookies

Festive gingerbread cookies with icing

Elevate the traditional Сhristmas gingerbread cookies to a new level by slathering them in rich eggnog icing. These cookies are a Christmas season must-try because of how well the rich, sweet flavour of the eggnog frosting complements the spicy warmth of the gingerbread. For those who enjoy the classic Christmas flavours but are searching for something a little new, these are ideal.

Meltaways with Chocolate Dipped Peppermint

Cookies with icing and crushed lollipop sticks

These Peppermint Meltaways with Chocolate Dipped Crunch are a delightful and refreshing treat. A layer of rich, melting chocolate nicely balances the cold, minty flavour of the peppermint extract-infused biscuits. A beautiful addition to any Christmas cookie collection is the mix of the soft, buttery cookie with the crisp chocolate shell and a whiff of peppermint.

The recipe for Christmas cookies is simple, but decorating them is a somewhat more difficult phase.

You may let your imagination run wild as you decorate cookies. The following useful advice may help you become more proficient at decorating cookies:

  • Consistent icing: Achieve the right icing consistency for easier piping and spreading. It shouldn't be too runny or too stiff.
  • Simple start: Begin with easy designs like dots, lines, or simple borders. As you gain confidence, experiment with more complex patterns.
  • Gel food colouring: Use gel food colouring for vibrant colours without altering the icing's consistency.
  • Piping bags and tips: Invest in quality piping bags and a variety of tips for different effects.
  • Let it dry: Allow your icing to dry completely before stacking or packaging cookies to maintain the design’s integrity.
  • Practise makes perfect: Don't be afraid to practise on parchment paper before decorating the actual cookies.

Baking, Cooling, and Storing Tips

To make your cookies last longer, you need to follow some rules, and here they are:

  • Preheat the oven: Ensure your oven is at the correct temperature for even baking.
  • Baking in batches: Avoid overcrowding the oven tray for uniform cooking.
  • Cooling cookies: Let cookies cool on the tray for a few minutes before transferring to a wire rack.
  • Storage: Keep cookies in an airtight container to maintain freshness. Layer with parchment paper to prevent sticking.
  • Freezing tips: You can freeze both dough and baked cookies. Thaw at room temperature before serving.
  • Reviving soft cookies: Re-crisp them in a low oven if they become soft over time.

The Enchantment of Making and Sharing Memories

The memories these cookies help generate are just as magical as their flavour. Imagine the pleasant talks, laughs and smiles these cookies will bring to your Christmas get-togethers. More than just a culinary hobby, baking fosters community, joy, and the weaving together of holiday customs.

Moreover, sharing is the true meaning of this, not only baking. Carry some of your work with you and share your happiness. Give them to your family, friends, and neighbours. A tiny bit of your heart, each cookie you serve is a charming representation of your thoughtfulness and joyous mood.

In closing, keep in mind that every Christmas cookie recipe in this post is a blank canvas waiting for your artistic interpretation as you set off on your holiday baking adventure. One cookie at a time, take advantage of the chance to create, share, and celebrate the marvels of the holiday season. Incorporate this guidance into your family's living traditions to give this Christmas and all subsequent ones a bit extra.

Thank you for your time and attention. If you are looking for more information, please visit our blog, where we cover everything you need to know about getting started with baking.

Looking for your perfect cake?

Our bakers are ready to make you your special cake, just the way you want it!

Frequently Asked
Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

We are here to help you with most frequently questions.

As specified in the instructions, assemble the required items. Every component has to be at room temperature. After combining the sugar and butter, add the dry ingredients to the wet mixture gradually and stir until smooth. Roll out the chilled dough and cut it into molds. Bake for 8–10 minutes at 350°F/175°C.

To make the icing easier to spread, you must get the proper consistency before you begin decorating Christmas cookies. Start with basic patterns like borders, dots, or lines. Try out increasingly intricate designs as you get more comfortable. To get vivid hues without altering the frosting's consistency, use gel food colouring. Before stacking or packing the cookies, the icing must totally dry to preserve the integrity of the pattern.

Use a kitchen scale or precision measuring cups to ensure consistency. For best mixing, the butter and eggs should be at room temperature. The dry ingredients should be sifted through a sieve to prevent lumps from forming. First, cream the butter and sugar until fluffy; add the eggs one at a time, and then mix in the dry ingredients until well blended. Add flavourings at the end.

Bake cookies according to your favorite recipe. Decorate the cookies with icing and add holiday patterns, colours, and embellishments. Let the icing harden before serving or packaging.

Rate this article!

(2 ratings, average: 5 out of 5)